Hi Simon,
I love your SidebarSlider, and if it becomes a plugin I really think it deserves to be an official and well promoted one!
I tested it with one of my single-file wikis, based on TW v5.3.5, and it works flawlessly (linux + Vivaldi browser).
Thanks for your work, and greetings from France,
Fred
Simon,
As an enhancement proposal, I’d like the default “Hide Sidebar” top-right button ($:/core/ui/TopBar/menu) to look like the example below when SidebarSlider plugin is active:
What do you think of this idea?
Fred
Hi @tw-FRed
Thanks! I don’t know if I can make this an official plugin, there are other plugins that create sidebar sliders that might be better suited, Idk.
Great that it works so well in your single-file wiki.
I found some flaws, especially when we start playing with unrealistic values for the minimal story width (like minimal story width greater than current story width) and I’ll try to find solutions for that
You mean the top right hide-sidebar button should disappear and such an indicator should appear on the sidebar slider?
Exactly. In LibreOffice, the slider works just like yours, and this indicator is a button which hides the panel when clicked. Overall the button works like current TW’s hide sidebar button, just located over the slider and with a different style.
Fred
Here is a capture of LibreOffice:
Fred
Agreed. I’ve never been happy with the current hide/show sidebar button. It’s distracting, and often interferes with other features in mobile. This would be much nicer!
Hi @tw-FRed
What should it [the Button] look like when the sidebar is hidden?
Where should it be positioned?
Thanks,
Simon
I think tt should be a button-sized column at full window height, along the right edge.
Inkscape uses the same mechanism, with a minor difference that in LibreOffice if you try and drag the sidebar too small, it simply wont let you, whilst in Inkscape it will pass a threshold and snap closed, the same as if it had been clicked on, and likewise can be dragged open and it’ll snap to minimum width. Anywhere along the vertical bar can be dragged to resize, but only the center button acts a button to do anything when clicked on. (I can try and work out how to gif the behaviour if needed)
as I understand it, the need to have a dynamic slider doesn’t exist on mobile devices, since the sidebar is now on top, with width dictated by the device, and height dictated by the content, so it’s simply an open/close toggle?
In which case, I think a horizontal bar full-width, to seperate content from the sidebar top content, with a tappable button in the middle, that collapses the top content and has just the bar along the top, with central button to expand again.
…I’m not sure this is great as it moves the control from the top of the top-content, to the bottom of it. Otoh, when the content is hidden, the current ‘show’ icon basically overlaps the topmost close ‘x’, so moving the tappable ‘show’ away from that would be a win IMHO.
Hi Simon,
I do like LibreOffice look and feel for this feature, and also its behavior.
In the gif I posted above LibreOffice displays a thin and high button in the vertical middle of the slider, with a right-facing triangle symbol when the sidebar is open, and an inverted left-facing triangle when it’s hidden. In hidden state, the slider and its button are still active, they just lay on the right edge of the window.
Although I seldom use TW on mobile, I agree with @nemo here: on narrow screens, TW’s UI already switches to an up/down layout where sidebar is above story. The slider, if any, could then work the same as horizontal layout, just vertically.
Have a nice day,
Fred
Hi @tw-FRed @nemo @Scott_Sauyet
I think I now changed it to your liking. Have a look if you have time and let me know…
In mobile I did not yet change anything, I’m not settled yet how that should behave
On firefox with the sidebar collapsed, the right vertical scroll bar keeps me from being able to click the new expand button. shift-alt-s required to get the sidebar back.
Ah yes, because it’s an overlay scrollbar on firefox, I get it…
That’s a problem
I made the button larger @john.edw_gmail.com
I’m not perfectly happy how it looks like but it’s functional
Same problem here, latest Firefox on Linux. [EDIT:] Problem solved with latest version 
Also tested with Vivaldi on Linux, works flawlessly!
Congratulations @BurningTreeC! The slider button is perfect! 
Fred
It looks fantastic to me!
I haven’t dug too deeply into the implementation – that’s a lot of tiddlers touched! – but there is something disconcerting about this using a property not in the $:/temp namespace, and hence having the “save” button immediately turn red on any move of the slider. But I don’t know that there’s any comfortable alternative. Sometimes using it would involve a temporary viewing convenience, and sometimes I would want it to be a permanent fix; not a situation easy to cater to.
Question: If I wanted to use this only in author mode, could I add the plugin, adjust my divider, and remove the plugin, leaving everything working as it was except for the new widths of the two sides?
Looks good (Windows + Chrome). But I don’t see how to move the sidebar to the left. There are no instructions or visible cues for that. It just lists that as a current feature.
$:/ControlPanel > Appearance > Theme Tweaks
has settings for “sidebar position” and “sidebar slider”.
